The Edvocate

Top Menu

  • Announcing the Winners of The 2017 Tech Edvocate Awards
  • Announcing the Winners of The 2018 Tech Edvocate Awards
  • Award Seals
  • Awards
  • My Speaking Page
  • Newsletter Sign Up Confirmation
  • Newsletter Unsubscription
  • Product Reviews
  • Ranking Methodology
  • Register
  • Signup
  • Start Here
    • Governance
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
  • The Awards Process
  • The Edvocate
  • Write For Us
  • Advertise

Main Menu

  • Start Here
    • Governance
    • Careers
    • Lynch Education Consulting
    • Dr. Lynch’s Personal Website
    • Product Reviews
    • Write For Us
    • My Speaking Page
    • Contact Us
  • PreK-12
    • Ask An Expert
    • Bullying
    • Early Childhood
    • Education News
    • EdTech & Innovation
    • Education Leadership
    • Elementary Education
    • Equity
    • First Year Teachers
    • Parental Involvement
    • Policy & Reform
    • Teachers
    • Testing
    • Year-Round Schooling
  • Higher Ed
    • Best Colleges and Universities
    • Diversity
    • HBCU’s
    • Higher Education
    • International Education
  • Advertise
  • Awards
    • The Awards Process
    • Announcing the Winners of The 2017 Tech Edvocate Awards
    • Announcing the Winners of The 2018 Tech Edvocate Awards
    • Award Seals
  • The Tech Edvocate

logo

  • Start Here
    • Governance
    • Careers
    • Lynch Education Consulting
    • Dr. Lynch’s Personal Website
    • Product Reviews
    • Write For Us
    • My Speaking Page
    • Contact Us
  • PreK-12
    • Ask An Expert
    • Bullying
    • Early Childhood
    • Education News
    • EdTech & Innovation
    • Education Leadership
    • Elementary Education
    • Equity
    • First Year Teachers
    • Parental Involvement
    • Policy & Reform
    • Teachers
    • Testing
    • Year-Round Schooling
  • Higher Ed
    • Best Colleges and Universities
    • Diversity
    • HBCU’s
    • Higher Education
    • International Education
  • Advertise
  • Awards
    • The Awards Process
    • Announcing the Winners of The 2017 Tech Edvocate Awards
    • Announcing the Winners of The 2018 Tech Edvocate Awards
    • Award Seals
  • The Tech Edvocate
  • How to Teach Math to Preschool Students

  • What Happens When Students Own Their Learning?

  • What Does a Future Ready College Student Look Like?

  • 10 Easy Ways to Show Students You Care

  • 3 Exciting Ways To Use Virtual Reality For Elearning

  • 27 Learner-Centered Instructional Strategies

  • 5 Steps to Asking Good Questions

  • 6 Reasons Why Lessons Fail

  • 17 Ways to Facilitate Student-Centered Learning

  • 5 Places to Find Free Readings for Your Students

Matthew LynchTeachers
Home›Matthew Lynch›Merit Pay in K-12 Education: What’s the Big Debate Over??

Merit Pay in K-12 Education: What’s the Big Debate Over??

By Matthew Lynch
November 16, 2015
0
Spread the love

One hotly contested issue is compensating teachers through merit pay. The philosophy behind merit pay is to reward teachers who produce better results in the classroom.

Sounds reasonable, right? Unfortunately, the issue is more complex than that. Districts with varying characteristics use merit pay for a number of reasons, including rewarding teachers for certification by the National Board for Professional Teaching Standards (NBPTS), teaching excellence, and recruiting and retaining teachers. And it’s important for you to know that the NEA adamantly opposes merit pay. Before you read more about merit pay, decide whether you agree, disagree, or are neutral about it. Jot down the reasons for your view. Now, let’s take a look at the arguments for and against merit pay.

Why should we use merit pay?

  • Americans value hard work and efficiency. Indeed, our entire capitalist system depends on rewarding those who work hard and produce results. Many people cite “the pay for results” explanation as the primary reason for their support of merit pay. In most professions, employees are offered bonuses and salary increases when they do exceptional work. Teaching should have similar rewards. Consider the scenario where a hardworking, decent teacher earns the same salary as a lazy, incompetent teacher.
  • Providing incentives to teachers will encourage them to teach better and work harder. Without the merit pay system, teachers have no monetary reasons to teach more effectively and work to produce better results. Providing extra cash to educators would most likely increase the motivation of many teachers to increase the quality of their teaching.
  • Merit pay programs will help recruit and retain high-quality teachers. Merit pay may encourage high-quality teachers to enter and remain in the profession. It is often upsetting to extraordinary teachers when they see their less-dedicated colleagues make equivalent salaries. Merit pay may help end the stream of educators leaving the profession because it’s not rewarding enough for their exceptional talents and diligence.
  • For those who believe that teachers are underpaid, merit pay will help to address this issue. As mentioned earlier, teaching is not an exceptionally well-paid profession. Both educators and non-educators find teacher salaries lacking compared to salaries in other professions. Merit pay would be one big step toward alleviating this problem. What better way is there to reward those who are most deserving?
  • America currently has a shortage of teachers. By implementing merit pay, teaching may become attractive enough to draw in fresh college graduates who may have been considering a teaching career. Merit pay would make teaching a viable career option for them, rather than an act of personal sacrifice.
  • The desperate condition of the American education system requires the consideration of all possibilities. Traditional methods of running schools and motivating teachers have resulted in limited success. In a time of crisis, we need to examine all valid ideas as a possible solution.

Why should we abandon the idea of merit pay?

  • When merit pay is based on student performance outcomes on standardized tests, teachers tend to focus on teaching to the test rather than their passion for teaching students. When test performance is the primary criterion for merit pay, the teachers’ primary focus becomes increasing student test scores, rather than teaching individual students. Additionally, standardized tests alone do not provide the best measure of a teacher’s performance.
  • Competition may arise among teachers, leading to a decline in cooperation and good will. In a non-merit pay system, teachers typically work as a team and help each other to arrive at good solutions. Under a merit pay system, teachers may develop a habit of looking out for themselves, resulting in a decline in cooperation. Ultimately, students will suffer and receive a lower-quality education.
  • Success is difficult, if not impossible, to define and measure. Many attempts to define success have failed miserably in the past. A good merit pay system will require a well-defined set of goals and outcomes for teachers to reach. Unfortunately, due to the complex nature of schools and students, defining such a set of goals will be nearly impossible.
  • Merit pay systems will encourage dishonesty and corruption. Teachers and administrators will be tempted to engage in dishonesty to receive more money. Merit pay systems create environments where legal and moral issues become problematic. An administrator’s favoritism toward some teachers over others could lead to an increase in lawsuits. Ultimately, our students will suffer from the corruption that a merit pay system will create.
  • Pay teachers more, period. Many opponents to the merit pay system propose increasing all teachers’ salaries. Improved salaries will attract and retain talented teachers.

Disagreements aside—advocates on both sides of the fence agree that teachers should be paid more.

What do you think of merit pay? Is it better to keep it or leave it?

 

 


Spread the love
Tagsntchatreflective teacherteacher qualityteachered
Previous Article

Research shows blended learning increases student achievement

Next Article

5 Professional Commitments You Need to Make ...

Matthew Lynch

Related articles More from author

  • DiversityEquityMatthew LynchPolicy & Reform

    2 Ways Educational Opportunity Has Risen 80 Percent Since 1970

    January 26, 2016
    By Matthew Lynch
  • Matthew LynchPolicy & ReformTeachers

    4 Tips Cash-Strapped Districts Can Use to Pay Teachers What They Deserve

    October 1, 2016
    By Matthew Lynch
  • Teachers

    3 Ways Teachers Mold America’s Future

    July 30, 2016
    By Matthew Lynch
  • PreK-12

    Saving School Libraries: How Technology and Innovation Help Them Stay Relevant

    October 15, 2016
    By Matthew Lynch
  • Higher Education

    Here’s another reason why many community college students do not get their degree

    November 25, 2016
    By Matthew Lynch
  • Matthew LynchPolicy & ReformTeachers

    How to Help Second-Language Learners Thrive in American Schools

    January 11, 2016
    By Matthew Lynch

Leave a reply Cancel reply

  • Education LeadershipMatthew Lynch

    Social Constructivism and Leadership

  • Education News

    Mississippi act aims to help special education students graduate

  • Higher Education

    Want college to be affordable? Start with Pell Grants

Search

Registration and Login

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries RSS
  • Comments RSS
  • WordPress.org

Newsletter

Signup for The Edvocate Newsletter and have the latest in P-20 education news and opinion delivered to your email address!

Ask an Expert

  • 2018 Global Edtech Inflencer's ListAsk An ExpertAssistive TechnologyBest of Best ListsBlack Boys in CrisisChild Development TechDigital & Mobile TechnologyEarly Childhood & K-12 EdTechEdTech & InnovationEdTech FuturesEdTech Policy & ReformEdTech Startups & BusinessesEducation LeadershipEquityFeaturedFirst Year TeachersHigher EducationHigher Education EdTechlistOnline Learning & eLearningParent & Family TechSTEMTeachers

    The Edvocate’s 2018 EdTech 20: A Ranking of 20 Global Edtech Influencers

    Spread the loveWho are the biggest edtech influencers in the world? The Edvocate editorial team has exhaustively researched the movers and shakers of edtech and selected 20 global influencers. To ...
  • Ask An ExpertEarly Childhood & K-12 EdTechFirst Year TeachersPersonalized LearningPreK-12Teachers

    How Can You Ignite English Language Learners’ Passion to Read & Learn?

    Spread the loveHanh Bui, 5th grade teacher at Aeolian Elementary School Instilling a passion for learning is one of the greatest gifts we can give our students. I strongly believe ...
  • Ask An ExpertModern ParentingSpecial Education

    Expressive and Receptive Language Disorders: What are They?

    Spread the loveChildren all learn language and speech using the same acquisition methods, but they do not always learn at the same pace. Some children pick up language early and ...
  • Ask An Expert

    Dyscalculia, Dysgraphia, Dysnomia, Dyslexia, and Dyspraxia: What are the Differences?

    Spread the loveIn my past life as a special education teacher, I worked with a variety of special needs students. These students were all unique, and so were their learning ...
  • Ask An ExpertTeachers

    Career Change Guide: Becoming a Teacher

    Spread the loveBy Daniel Karell There is a growing teacher crisis in the United States. The Learning Policy Institute (LPI) estimates there was a shortage of 64,000 teachers in primary ...

International Education

  • Higher EducationInternational Education

    The A-Z of Education Blogs: Letters F-H

    Spread the loveClick here to access all of the articles in this series. In this multi-part series, we are profiling the best of the best education blogs, in alphabetical order. ...
  • Higher EducationInternational Education

    What would The UK government’s plans to cut student immigration by 50% mean for education ...

    Spread the loveThe UK government is planning on slashing non-EU expat student numbers almost in half from 300,000 to 170,000 under tougher student visa rules. The threat is being greeted ...
  • International Education

    Why pushing undocumented children out of schools won’t help bring down net migration

    Spread the loveThis article was written by Nando Sigona Leaked cabinet papers seen by the BBC suggest that back when she was home secretary, Theresa May wanted schools to carry ...
  • Education NewsInternational Education

    Why it doesn’t help — and may harm — to fail pupils with poor math ...

    Spread the loveThis article was written by Elizabeth Walton Many South Africans were outraged by the recent announcement that for 2016, pupils in Grades 7 to 9 could progress to ...
  • International EducationPolicy & Reform

    It’s time to rethink teacher training

    Spread the loveThis article was written by James Williams Over the past six years, we’ve had calls for teachers to be trained in everything from protecting girls from female genital ...

Early Childhood Education

  • Child DevelopmentEarly ChildhoodFeaturedFreshInfographicsParental InvolvementParenting

    5 Steps to Asking Good Questions

    Spread the loveThere is an adage that posits that there is no such thing as a bad question. However, if you ask the wrong question, odds are you will not ...
  • Early ChildhoodModern ParentingParenting

    How to Avoid Raising Racist Kids

    Spread the loveFrom race-based killings to white supremacist rallies, we are living in times when racism is on the front page of every newspaper. For this reason, many race-conscious parents ...
  • Child DevelopmentEarly ChildhoodModern ParentingParenting

    7 Ways to Teach Children Civility

    Spread the loveUnfortunately, our children are learning that those who are uncivil seem to get ahead. Celebrity culture and political warfare encourage the opposite of civility. The ones who shout ...
  • Early ChildhoodParenting

    What Fathers Should Teach Their Sons

    Spread the loveWhile it’s true that not all families are the same in today’s society, there are still some key lessons which are best passed down from father to son. ...
  • Early ChildhoodElementary Education

    Number Sense Skills are the Bedrock of Mathematics

    Spread the loveBy Chad Malcolm Counting and Cardinality is only a standard in Kindergarten for the CCSS. However, this does not mean it cannot be strengthen every year moving forward. ...

Matthew Lynch

  • listMatthew LynchPolicy & Reform

    18 Reasons the U.S. Education System is Failing

    Spread the loveOnce upon a time, enthusiasts designed a formal education system to meet the economic demands of the industrial revolution. Fast forward to today and, with the current global ...
  • Higher EducationMatthew Lynch

    A Free College Education: A Basic American Right?

    Spread the loveEarning a college education is something that is a double-edged sword for the nation’s youngest adults and for some of their parents too. Society dictates that some form ...
  • Matthew LynchPolicy & Reform

    Year-Round Schooling: How it Affects Students

    Spread the loveThe traditional school year, with roughly three months of vacation days every summer, was first implemented when America was an agricultural society. The time off was not implemented ...
  • Matthew LynchOpEducation

    Disengaged Students, Part 11: The Irrationality of Modern Politics

    Spread the loveIn this 20-part series, I explore the root causes and effects of academic disengagement in K-12 learners and explore the factors driving American society ever closer to being ...
  • EdTech & InnovationMatthew LynchOpEducation

    Disengaged Students, Part 7: Too Much Information Access?

    Spread the loveIn this 20-part series, I explore the root causes and effects of academic disengagement in K-12 learners and explore the factors driving American society ever closer to being ...

Testing

  • TestingTrending Topics

    7 Things That Educators Should Know About Assessment and Evaluation

    Spread the loveAssessment refers to judging a student’s rate of academic achievement by analyzing the available evidence, such as quizzes, tests or written tasks. Assessments take different forms, and each ...
  • Child DevelopmentOpEducationPersonalized LearningTesting

    Intelligence in America: Time to Test Something New

    Spread the loveMeasuring the progress of any endeavor requires a definition of success. Education, by its very nature, is difficult to ascribe a single definition of success; “making people smarter” ...
  • TestingTrending Topics

    The A-Z of Education: Assessment and Evaluation

    Spread the loveIn this series, I hope to guide you in acquiring the vocabulary that you need to know to be considered a competent education professional. In this article, we ...
  • Matthew LynchTeachersTesting

    Three Handy Rubrics for Assessment Creation

    Spread the loveWhen it comes to creating classroom assessments, educators have a lot of leeway as to form, content, and length. Sometimes, the breadth available can be a little overwhelming. ...
  • TeachersTesting

    The Five Major Features of Summative Assessments

    Spread the loveCreating a classroom assessment that best quantifies your students’ learning can be tricky business. Because of their broad scope but specific content focus, summative assessments can be a ...

Special Reports

  • Ask An ExpertEarly Childhood & K-12 EdTechFirst Year TeachersPersonalized LearningPreK-12Teachers

    How Can You Ignite English Language Learners’ Passion to Read & Learn?

    Spread the loveHanh Bui, 5th grade teacher at Aeolian Elementary School Instilling a passion for learning is one of the greatest gifts we can give our students. I strongly believe ...
  • Education LeadershipPreK-12Teachers

    Verified Service Learning Feeds the “Whole Student”

    Spread the loveTeachers and schools and school districts track grades. We all know, or can find out pretty easily, what mark a particular student made on a specific assignment or ...
  • Early ChildhoodEducation LeadershipElementary EducationHigher EducationK-12OpEducationPreK-12

    What Preschool Can Teach Us About Choice and Opportunity

    Spread the loveThere is a pantheon of sitcom cliches that, no matter how many times they’ve been done before, always turn up in new ones. Among the repeat offenders: outrageously ...
  • Best of Best ListsDiversityEarly ChildhoodEdTech & InnovationElementary EducationK-12PreK-12SpeakingTeachers

    The Cautionary Tale of Story

    Spread the love  Teachers have been telling stories for as long as teachers have taught others. Students are still learning from the stories of our greatest teachers thousands of years ...
  • Early ChildhoodOpEducationPolicy & ReformPreK-12

    Time to Reboot the Safety Lecture

    Spread the loveWhen we play the perennial favorite game of Blaming Other Generations, we tend to focus on relative merits and deficiencies: which generation is more or less polite, hard-working, ...

RSS Matthew on Education Week

  • 5 Common Questions People Have About Learning Apps April 20, 2018 Matthew Lynch
  • What is the Future of STEM Education? April 2, 2018 Matthew Lynch
  • How to Create a Student-Run 'Genius Bar' March 28, 2018 Matthew Lynch
  • How Artificial Intelligence Is Already Transforming Education March 14, 2018 Matthew Lynch
  • How Google is Taking Over the Classroom March 6, 2018 Matthew Lynch

About Us

The Edvocate was created in 2014 to argue for shifts in education policy and organization in order to enhance the quality of education and the opportunities for learning afforded to P-20 students in America. What we envisage may not be the most straightforward or the most conventional ideas. We call for a relatively radical and certainly quite comprehensive reorganization of American’s P-20 system.

That reorganization, though, and the underlying effort, will have much to do with reviving the American education system, and reviving a national love of learning.  The Edvocate plans to be one of key architects of this revival, as it continues to advocate for education reform, equity, and innovation.

Newsletter

Signup for The Edvocate Newsletter and have the latest in P-20 education news and opinion delivered to your email address!

Contact

The Edvocate
5322 Markel Road, Suite 104
Richmond, VA 23230
(601) 630-5238
advocatefored@gmail.com

Follow us

Copyright (c) 2018 Matthew Lynch. All rights reserved.